Most families choose a home care agency under time pressure, often in the fortnight after something has gone wrong. Websites all say much the same thing, every agency sounds caring, and it is hard to tell from the outside which one will actually turn up on a wet Tuesday in February.
These are the questions worth asking, and more usefully, what a good answer sounds like compared with one that should give you pause.
Key takeaways
- Work out what you actually need before you start ringing round, or every agency will sound equally suitable.
- Any agency providing personal care in England must be registered with the Care Quality Commission. This is a legal requirement, not a badge.
- A new service may be registered but not yet inspected or rated. That is normal, and worth asking about rather than ruling out.
- Continuity of carer is the single thing families raise most often after the first few months.
- Ask how the agency handles the things that go wrong: sickness, lateness, a carer who isn’t the right fit.
- Vagueness about money, staffing or complaints is more telling than anything on the website.
Before you start ringing round
Spend twenty minutes writing down what support is actually needed and when. Which tasks, which times of day, how many days a week, and what matters most to the person receiving care rather than to you.
Without that, every agency sounds fine, because you have nothing concrete to test their answers against. It also makes the quotes you get back genuinely comparable. If you would like the council involved, a needs assessment is the formal version of the same exercise.
10 questions to ask a home care agency
- 1. Are you registered with the Care Quality Commission? In England this is a legal requirement for anyone providing personal care. You can check on the CQC website rather than taking their word for it.
- 2. What is your rating, and when were you last inspected? Ratings run from Outstanding to Inadequate. A newer service may be registered but not yet inspected, which is normal. In that case ask how they meet the standards day to day.
- 3. How many different carers will we see? The answer families care about most. A small, named group is a good sign. “Whoever is available” is not.
- 4. What happens if our regular carer is off sick or on holiday? Every agency has this problem. The good ones have a clear answer about who covers and how you find out.
- 5. How do you recruit and check your carers? You are listening for DBS checks, references, and what training people get before they start, not only what they get eventually.
- 6. How are visits timed, and what counts as late? Ask what happens if a carer is running behind and whether you would be told. Medication visits in particular need to be reliable.
- 7. Who writes the care plan, and how often is it reviewed? It should be built with the person receiving care, not written about them, and revisited as things change.
- 8. What exactly does it cost, and what isn’t included? Ask about evenings, weekends, bank holidays, mileage, minimum visit lengths and notice periods for changes. Ask for it in writing. Our guide to what home care costs per hour sets out typical 2026 rates to compare against.
- 9. How do we raise a concern, and what happens then? Ask for the complaints process and, more revealingly, for an example of something that went wrong recently and what changed as a result.
- 10. Can we meet the carer before they start? Not always possible at short notice, but a willingness to try says something about how the agency thinks about the relationship.
What good looks like
The regulator publishes what to expect from a good care service, based on what inspectors look for. It is a useful benchmark to read before you make calls, because it gives you something firmer than instinct to measure answers against.
Alongside that, these are the answers worth paying attention to.
| A good sign | Worth pausing on |
|---|---|
| Specific numbers for how many carers you’d see | “We’ll do our best to keep it consistent” |
| Written pricing covering evenings and weekends | A single hourly rate with no detail behind it |
| A clear answer on sickness cover | Reluctance to admit cover is ever needed |
| Willingness to describe something that went wrong | A claim that nothing ever does |
| Questions back to you about the person needing care | A sales pitch that never asks who they are |
What matters once care has started
Most of the questions above are about the first week. The thing families raise with us months later is almost always continuity: whether the same people keep turning up, whether they remember how your mum takes her tea, whether anyone notices when something is a bit off.
That is not a feature you can verify on a website, which is why asking directly about carer numbers and cover matters more than it might seem at the time. When you are comparing home care providers, it is worth weighting that question heavily.
Hestia Home Care is GP-led and family-run. We pay our carers above average and hire for attitude, because carers who feel valued stay, and carers who stay are how continuity actually happens rather than being promised.
“Ask any agency what happens when things go wrong. The ones worth choosing will tell you, because they have thought about it. The answer tells you more than the brochure ever will.”
Emma Trewin, GP and Co-Founder, Hestia Home Care
Your questions about choosing a home care agency answered
Does a home care agency have to be CQC registered?
In England, yes, if it provides personal care such as help with washing, dressing or medication. You can check a provider’s registration and any inspection report on the CQC website before you commit to anything.
What if an agency has no CQC rating yet?
A newly registered service will not have been inspected straight away, so it may show as registered but not yet rated. That is normal and not a red flag on its own. Ask how they meet the standards in practice, and weigh the answer alongside everything else.
How many carers should we expect to see?
There is no fixed rule, but a small named group is what most families are hoping for. Ask for a number rather than a reassurance, and ask what happens when someone in that group is away.
Should we use an agency or employ a carer directly?
Employing directly is usually cheaper per hour, but you take on recruitment, checks, insurance, payroll and cover when that person is ill or on holiday. An agency costs more because it carries those things for you. Which is right depends on how much you are able to take on.
Can we change agency if it isn’t working?
Yes. Check the notice period before you sign anything, so you know what changing your mind would involve. A reasonable notice period is itself a reasonable thing to ask about.
Ask us anything on that list
We’d far rather you asked us the difficult questions now than wondered about them later. Get in touch and we’ll answer them straight.
